A powerful Nor'easter that battered Nantucket with heavy winds and high seas over the weekend of Sept. 26, 2026, exposed the wooden bones of what appears to be a long-buried shipwreck on the island's south shore, reviving a mystery first investigated four years ago. The newly visible timbers, protruding from the sand in the unmistakable shape of a hull, are believed to be the remains of the schooner Warren Sawyer, a cargo vessel that went ashore in a storm on the night of Dec. 22, 1884.
The discovery began not with archaeologists but with a phone call. Jason Graziadei, editor-in-chief of the Nantucket Current, was covering the Nor'easter when a reader reached out with an unusual observation. "I found what I believe to be a shipwreck uncovered by the storm," the tipster wrote. The tip came from David DeHart, an island resident who had noticed something unusual while walking the beach during the height of the storm.
Graziadei, who had driven out with his son Owen to survey the storm's effects, confirmed that the remains were exactly where DeHart had said they would be. The find is on Point of Breakers, a south shore beach known for its relentless surf and shifting sands — conditions that can both bury a wreck in a season and strip it bare in a day. Photos of the site show waves washing over exposed timbers set at an angle in the sand, the geometry of the hull still readable more than a century and a half after the vessel broke apart.
Crucially, this is not the first time fragments have surfaced in that location. When pieces of the wreck were discovered in 2022, they were documented in the same stretch of beach where the 2026 timbers have now reappeared. That earlier encounter set off the archaeological work that produced the tentative identification, and it suggests the site sits within a deposit of wreckage rather than a single scattering of driftwood.
The 2022 inspection was led by David Robinson, director and chief archeologist for the Massachusetts Board of Underwater Archeological Resources. Robinson spent several months studying the site and working alongside researchers at the Egan Maritime Institute and the Nantucket Historical Association, groups with deep familiarity with Nantucket's shipping history. Together, they assembled a body of evidence — archival records, historic photographs, published literature and direct archaeological observation — in an effort to answer a narrow question: does the wreckage on Point of Breakers belong to the Warren Sawyer?
In 2023, Robinson told the Nantucket Current that the effort was deliberately methodical. "As with most historical archaeological research," he said, the team worked through the "literature, archival, photographic, and archaeological evidence" available for the site in order to reach a conclusive determination about whether the wreckage came from the sailing vessel. That caution is telling: even after months of work, the conclusion remained framed as a likelihood rather than a certainty.
The candidate identification points to a vessel with a specific and traceable final voyage. The Warren Sawyer was a cargo ship carrying bales of cotton and scrap metal from New Orleans to Boston when it crashed on Nantucket's south shore during the night of Dec. 22, 1884. A short, violent crossing in a winter storm would have been enough to end such a voyage, and the storm-driven grounding is what makes the identification plausible — the same conditions that have just revealed the timbers are the conditions that likely destroyed the ship.
The rediscovery also illustrates a dynamic familiar to anyone who has walked a Cape Cod or island beach after a nor'easter: major storms act as both preservers and excavators. Sand and gravel that protected a hull for decades can be moved offshore in a single tide, while debris that had settled inland is left standing clear of the waterline. What reemerges is usually a partial record — ribs, planking, fastenings — and the interpretive work of matching fragments to a named ship is slow.
The route from beach to newspaper has been notably short. A local resident's tip, relayed to a local editor, brought the site to national attention within a day, and the underlying research had already been done years earlier. Graziadei's account of the trip — finding the timbers precisely where DeHart had described them — underscores how much of this story rests on island residents who know these beaches intimately enough to recognize when something beneath them has changed.
The practical questions now are likely to be the slow ones. Archaeologists will want to re-document the newly exposed timbers in place, compare the 2026 exposure with what was recorded in 2022, and assess whether the hull is eroding, intact, or already collapsing back into the sand. Any further work would likely continue through the same partnership that produced the earlier determination, drawing on archival and documentary research to firm up — or challenge — the link to the Warren Sawyer.
For Nantucket, the episode underscores the density of maritime history packed into a few miles of shoreline. Islands like Nantucket sit on layers of ordinary catastrophe: vessels that came ashore, cargoes that washed up, storms that rearranged the coast. Nearly every nor'easter offers a chance to see that history surface briefly, and the 2026 storm appears to have delivered on the tip of one attentive island resident. The remains will not be conclusively dated by the photographs alone, but the discovery has set in motion again a process that had reached a careful, provisional verdict — and made the case, once more, for a local tip line worth watching.
(0)